About

Here you can find all forums, blogs and similar sections, that are meant for different types of communication.

#1323

Simbiat
Simbiat

Good art and animation. Music is decent, although I can't say that it hooked me. The story...

Well, it's there, definitely. And the episode does teach us all a good lesson (at least one). But this feels more like an episode 0 or OVA/ODA/whatever, rather than the actual episode 1, since despite the title there is no travelling in it.

Let's see how it goes. So far I have a feeling, that it may be wholesome anime of the fall 2020 replacing (at least partially) Somali To Mori No Kamisama.

#1324

Simbiat
Simbiat

Episode 2:

 

Did not think Elaine would be so evil: force young witch to eat all those mushrooms, that Elaine herself does not like... On the other hand, perhaps, Saya deserved it.

Regardless, as I expected it was quite wholesome. For some reason I was reminded of Violet Evergarden, although quite a bit "calmer".

#1325

Simbiat
Simbiat

Episode 3:

This episode sure was quite darker than previous, but not dark enough. Probably because of Elaine herself and that' why I will be dropping this anime.

You see, this is an anthology, in essence. Only the 1st episode bared any "overall plot". While I do not dislike anthologies (I like Black Mirror, Into The Dark, Room 401, for example), in this case there is one major flaw for me: forcing a certain character in.

I am fine with forcing a certain place, like with Room 401, where all stories take place in that room. It forces a location, that can be made to work for you. I mean, motel room is motel room, nothing special about it. Forcing a character in forces a certain perception of the events though.

Yes, in this episode Elaine was more of a bystander, but she still had reactions, she had memories of similar stories she heard/read, and thus she had emotions, her own thoughts. If this was just 1 episode with Elaine narrating it - that could work (I think Black Mirror had some episode with narrator), since you hear a story and then move on. Even if she was always the narrator for all the stories - that's cool too, I think Tales From The Crypt had that approach.

But narrator is not exactly a character. He may have his thoughts on the events, but is generally impartial to them. Here, though... You have narrator actively play a part, albeit small one. And the character will not change much if at all during the whole show. Meaning, that there will always be some kind of bias from Elaine's perspective.

I can't live with that. The show in general is not bad, it has good art and decent CGI even. But I do not want to be told how to feel about a story by the "narrator", even if that's not her goal.